|
VS |
|
|
|
| NDD + STP + DMA + DMT + ECN pricing |
|
NDD + STP |
|
ECN (Electronic Communication Network)
NDD - No Dealing Desk
STP - Straight Through Processing
DMA - Direct Market Access to the Top-tier liquidity
DMT - Direct Market Trading within ECN liquidity pools
ECN pricing - ECN bid/ask quotes |
|
STP (Straight Through Processing)
NDD - No Dealing Desk
STP - Straight Through Processing |
|
| ECN is a Network |
|
STP is the method of processing orders |
|
Top-tier liquidity network, trading is done inside the network |
|
Orders are passed straight through to a specific liquidity provider (LP), execution is done at the LP's side |
|
| ECN broker is an Agent |
|
STP broker is an Agent |
|
ECN brokers don't fill client orders, all orders are passed to the ECN liquidity pool, where ECN participants become counterparties to clients' trades |
|
STP brokers don't fill client orders either, all orders are passed to another liquidity provider, who executes the order and becomes a counterparty |
|
| Multiple Top-tier liquidity providers |
|
Few or a Single liquidity provider |
|
Unlimited number of Top-tier 1-3 liquidity providers - ECN participants |
|
A few liquidity providers, but oftentimes just 1 Brokerage company to whom all orders are sent for execution. This company can also be a sister company of the STP broker |
|
| Raw ECN pricing |
|
Single broker pricing |
|
Raw market prices currently traded on ECN |
|
Orders are executed at Market Maker prices |
|
| Strictly professional clients |
|
Available to retail & professional clients |
|
High requirements towards experience level and capital |
|
No requirements towards experience level or capital |
|
| Highest deposit requirement |
|
Lowest deposit requirement |
|
Average minimum deposit is $50,000 (but no less than $10,000 USD) |
|
STP accounts start from $1 USD |
|
| Leverage less than 1 : 100 |
|
High leverage |
|
Due to the nature of ECN trading, leverage above 1 : 100 is unsustainable |
|
No leverage limits, can go as high as 1 : 3000 |
|
| Minimum trade size from 0.1 standard lot |
|
Minimum trade size from 0.001 standard lot |
|
ECN brokers don't offer micro lots. The 0.1 minimum lot size cap is the requirement set by liquidity providers |
|
STP brokers are able to offer lowest minimum lot size |
|
| Maximum trade size unlimited |
|
Maximum trade size is capped |
|
No limits on trade size and volume |
|
Limits set depending on the processing capacity of a final destination broker (LP) |
|
| Low commission |
|
No commission |
|
Low commission, goes even lower with higher trading volume |
|
STP brokers don't charge commission |
|
| Floating spreads |
|
Floating or fixed spreads |
|
Only floating spreads |
|
Spread type depends on the Market Maker executing orders, it can be fixed or floating. A fixed spread means there is only 1 Market Maker executing orders for STP, oftentimes it's a sister company. |
|
| Trade inside the spread |
|
no |
|
Traders can place orders between the highest Bid and the lowest Ask price, e.g. become "price makers" |
|
Trading on given spreads only, e.g. "price taking" |
|
| Trade against other traders |
|
no |
|
Traders can trade against other traders, market makers or anyone else in the ECN network |
|
no |
|
| Unlimited access to Market Depth (DOM) |
|
No access to Market Depth (DOM) |
|
Traders can see true ECN liquidity |
|
DOM is not available |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|